Thursday, November 19, 2026

Ponder: Rules for Breaking

Rules for Breaking ©2015  is the second book in The Rules young adult series by Ashley Elston. My previous post published 11/9/26 reviews the first book in the series, The Rules for Disappearing, which I rated five stars. The Rules for Disappearing, was complete in and of itself and did not end in a cliffhanger, but with a niggling question of what happens next. I'd became invested enough in Meg's family and the budding relationships that I did want to find out what happened next. The second book in this two part series was a quick easy read and was an action packed page turner. I read it in one day, during one long sitting, with only a couple grudgingly necessary interruptions. I did enjoy it but mainly because of the groundwork laid in the first book.


In this second book Meg's name goes back to Anna, her given name before multiple changes within the Witness Protection Program. Anna is relieved to be released from the program and able to stay in one location, put down roots, have a stable home, and make friends. But perhaps closure from the shielding program is not 100%. There may still be someone from her past that is out to get her and do her harm. Anna is reluctant to disclose this suspicion to her parents and the security agents for fear of being thrust back into the instability and loneliness of the Witness Protection Program. Seventeen year old Anna decides to weather the danger on her own.

I felt The Rules for Breaking lacked the depth of characters of its predecessor; I expected character growth from the first book and did not see that forthcoming. Also the number of characters shrunk and the majority of those in the first book were only peripheral in the second book. A few new characters were introduced but not developed in depth. Rules for Breaking was more action focused rather than character focused. Rather than many plot twists, there were many characters twists. Who can be trusted and who cannot kept flip-flopping. Although the author did do a satisfactorily adequate job of bringing a reader up to pace had they not read the first book, still, this book would have less appeal to those who have not read The Rules for Disappearing. I demote the rating for The Rules for Breaking to three stars.

This is the sixth book I have enjoyed by Ashley Elston. I have read two adults novels and four YA novels by Ashley Elston and rated five of them highly.  The Rules for Breaking breaks the pattern but not by a lot and mainly because I think its audience is limited. Following is the list of those six books followed by the dates I posted my review of each. I still will be on the lookout for other books by Ashley Elston.

5 stars First Lie Wins ©2024 (adult)  — see post for 9/6/24
5 stars The Lying Woods ©2019  (young adult)  — see post for 10/8/24
4 stars This Is Our Story ©2016 (young adult)  — see post for 10/29/24
5 stars Anatomy of an Alibi ©2026  (adult)  — see post for 10/14/26
5 stars Rules for Disappearing ©2013 (young adult) — see post for 11/9/26
3 stars Rules for Breaking ©2015 (young adult)  — see this post 11/19/26
 
★★★☆☆ Better than average; not a waste of time

No comments:

Post a Comment