My first read of 2026, The Black Wolf ©2025 by Louise Penny, was unfortunately a real loser for me. Goodreads rated this novel 4.2 stars (23,1776 ratings) and Amazon readers rated it 4.4 stars (13,076 ratings), so I expected my enjoyment to be commensurate. Nevertheless, I rate The Black Wolf a dismal one star. What a bummer of a way to start the new year!
Louise Penny has been a favorite author of mine and I have read all her novels. I revel in the serenity and the characters in the secluded village of Three Pines. Although these characters did make cameo appearances and lead detective Armand Gamache seemed to work remotely from the village as much as possible, the local people and setting seemed to be only a feeble homage to satisfy readers' desire for these features. This was not a murder mystery with precisely developed characters, motives, clues, and alibis but rather a huge, impersonal, international plot of a politically motivated power grab.
There were too many people with titles and political positions for me to follow. Even if I had created a chart or list as I progressed through the book, none of these persons were assigned a personality in depth. Each identity was not sufficient enough for me to align myself with either rooting for them or loathing them. Also the plot was too expansive and disjointed. I do admit I was very biased by my present disgust of the Trump administration's tactics in promoting domestic and international turmoil. This novel, rather than engage me, upset me, and was the opposite extreme of providing an enjoyable reading experience. I completed
The Black Wolf but I rate it only
one star.
★☆☆☆☆ Awful but I read most or maybe even all of it
I am rethinking my intention of reading all of Louise Penny's books. I realize an author needs to grow and not churn out the same story over and over. But I am also learning that I prefer a "whodunnit" with quirky characters and a plot I can follow. If that makes me an immature, politically ignorant reader, so be it. Reading should be for pleasure. I still prefer dessert over the main course. I suspect this author is "growing" in a direction that diverges from my preferences. Here is a quick review of my rating of her past books. Near the end of
my 1/28/25 post on The Grey Wolf are the blog post links for my review of each of these novels.
